<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0">
    <teiHeader>
        <fileDesc>
            <titleStmt>
                <title>In Search of Compromise</title>
                <author>
                    <name>
                        <forename>Filip</forename>
                        <surname>Čuček</surname>
                    </name>
                </author>
            </titleStmt>
            <editionStmt>
                <edition><date>2015-11-04</date></edition>
            </editionStmt>
            <publicationStmt>
                <publisher>
                    <orgName xml:lang="sl">Inštitut za novejšo zgodovino</orgName>
                    <orgName xml:lang="en">Institute of Contemporary History</orgName>
                    <address>
                        <addrLine>Kongresni trg 1</addrLine>
                        <addrLine>SI-1000 Ljubljana</addrLine>
                    </address>
                </publisher>
                <pubPlace>http://ojs.inz.si/pnz/article/view/118</pubPlace>
                <date>2015</date>
                <availability status="free">
                    <licence>http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/</licence>
                </availability>
            </publicationStmt>
            <seriesStmt>
                <title xml:lang="sl">Prispevki za novejšo zgodovino</title>
                <title xml:lang="en">Contributions to Contemporary History</title>
                <biblScope unit="volume">55</biblScope>
                <biblScope unit="issue">3</biblScope>
                <idno type="ISSN">2463-7807</idno>
            </seriesStmt>
            <sourceDesc>
                <p>No source, born digital.</p>
            </sourceDesc>
        </fileDesc>
        <encodingDesc>
            <projectDesc xml:lang="en">
                <p>Contributions to Contemporary History is one of the central Slovenian scientific
                    historiographic journals, dedicated to publishing articles from the field of
                    contemporary history (the 19th and 20th century).</p>
                <p>The journal is published three times per year in Slovenian and in the following
                    foreign languages: English, German, Serbian, Croatian, Bosnian, Italian, Slovak
                    and Czech. The articles are all published with abstracts in English and
                    Slovenian as well as summaries in English.</p>
            </projectDesc>
            <projectDesc xml:lang="sl">
                <p>Prispevki za novejšo zgodovino je ena osrednjih slovenskih znanstvenih
                    zgodovinopisnih revij, ki objavlja teme s področja novejše zgodovine (19. in 20.
                    stoletje).</p>
                <p>Revija izide trikrat letno v slovenskem jeziku in v naslednjih tujih jezikih:
                    angleščina, nemščina, srbščina, hrvaščina, bosanščina, italijanščina, slovaščina
                    in češčina. Članki izhajajo z izvlečki v angleščini in slovenščini ter povzetki
                    v angleščini.</p>
            </projectDesc>
        </encodingDesc>
        <revisionDesc>
            <listChange>
                <change>
                    <date>2015-11-04</date>
                    <name>Andrej Pančur</name>
                    <desc>Pretvorba iz DOCX v TEI, dodatno kodiranje</desc>
                </change>
            </listChange>
        </revisionDesc>
    </teiHeader>
    <text xml:lang="en">
        <front>
            <docAuthor>Filip Čuček</docAuthor>
        </front>
        <body>
            <head>Janez Cvirn: Dunajski državni zbor in Slovenci (1848-1918) [Vienna National Assembly
                and Slovenians (1848-1918)]. Zgodovinsko društvo Celje, Znanstvena založba
                Filozofske fakultete Ljubljana. Celje, Ljubljana 2015, 280 pages</head>
            <p>Based on several years of research into the issue of parliamentarism in the Austrian
                Monarchy, the late Prof. Dr. Janez Cvirn (1960–2013) published a university textbook
                entitled Razvoj ustavnosti in parlamentarizma v habsburški monarhiji (dunajski
                državni zbor in Slovenci 1848 – 1918) [Development of Constitutionality and
                Parliamentarism in the Habsburg Monarchy: Vienna National Assembly and Slovenians
                (1848-1918)]. This textbook was far more than what its name suggested and indicated
                that the author was about to realise even more ambitious plans regarding this
                subject. Those of us who were close to him knew that he was also planning a book
                edition, i.e. a thorough and comprehensive history of Austrian parliamentarism (and
                the Slovenian experience within its context). However, he was not able to realise
                this project (the book was supposed to be published by another publisher a few years
                ago but, unfortunately, was not). It was finally co-published posthumously by the
                Historical Society of Celje and the Faculty of Arts of Ljubljana (also in
                cooperation with the Institute of Contemporary History – the book was edited by Dr.
                Jure Gašparič). Cvirn’s book is an essential source for studying the political
                history of the second half of the 19<hi rend="superscript">th</hi> century and, as
                such, finally available in Slovenian libraries and bookstores as the last, fifteenth
                book of the collection Zgodovini.ce, based on Cvirn’s idea (with this book the Celje
                book collection is therefore completed). Regrettably, Cvirn will not be able to
                read, evaluate or in any way assess this book, but I am convinced that he would
                certainly approve of it, as it is.</p>
            <p>Cvirn has profoundly marked Slovenian historiography with his work and is considered
                the leading Slovenian expert in the history of the 19<hi rend="superscript">th</hi>
                century. In his final work, which is a result of systematic research, he presented
                the crucial turning points in the constitutional history of Austria – from the first
                steps toward constitutionalism in 1848 until the end of the Monarchy in 1918. Apart
                from that, the book is an exhaustive political-historical overview, as the author
                analysed the relationships between the governments and the parliament and thus
                described the role of the Austrian National Assembly in the political life of the
                state. The book also contains a detailed presentation of the activities of the
                Slovenian deputies (who had always been forced to resort to opportunistic politics
                because of their limited numbers) in the National Assembly between 1848 and 1918,
                which is particularly valuable.</p>
            <p>Let us take a quick glance at the book. The early constitutionalism, established
                especially by certain (south) German states in the pre-March period, was very slow
                to penetrate the conservative Austria on the eve of the March revolution. Only the
                revolution encouraged the Court to rely on the new societal model. However, the
                April (Pillersdorf) Constitution which, as the author convincingly demonstrates,
                followed constitutionalism only as far as to clearly enforce the separation of
                powers (judicial, executive and legislative), still conferred many powers on the
                emperor. The author then presents the initiative of the Provincial (Estate)
                Assemblies which joined the reform movement. The National Assembly elections in June
                1848, establishing the first Austrian Parliament, were even more important. Cvirn
                analyses the elections in detail and notes, among other things, that the national
                component is indisputably a result of the political development of the later period.</p>
            <p>With the imposed constitution the young Emperor Franz Joseph demonstrated that
                concessions to the revolution had come to an end. The author skilfully guides us
                through the developments which led to the neo-absolutist regime through the New
                Year’s Eve Patents, thus ending the early constitutional period in Austria. A
                ten-year period of resumed "silence", personified by the Minister of the Interior
                Bach, was followed by the restoration of the constitutional life in 1860/61, when
                the period of oppression and censorship had, in a moral and material sense, come to
                an end. However, the creator of the new political course Anton Schmerling added a
                "German character" to the Austrian parliamentarism with his electoral structure,
                which also favoured the wealthier strata on the basis of a tax and intelligence
                census. The author thus offers a sound and coherent description of the development
                of political thought until the introduction of dualism in 1867, when Cisleithania
                was forced to re-establish the state-legal foundations of the Austrian half of the
                Monarchy and provide for the further (political) modernisation of the state with the
                December Constitution. The author then meticulously highlights individual issues
                concerning the directly-elected Vienna National Assembly (from 1873 on) and presents
                them through a perspective related to the functioning of governments and each
                convening of the Parliament. Cvirn does not conclude his work before World War I, as
                it would be expected, but follows the Austrian parliamentary life until the fall of
                the Monarchy.</p>
            <p>One of the basic findings of Cvirn’s book is that the dissolution of the Monarchy
                was not a consequence of a belated and insufficient political democratisation. As it
                was, the liberal December Constitution of 1867 transformed Cisleithania into a
                relatively modern constitutional monarchy, which, as far as democracy was concerned,
                did not exhibit a significant lag in comparison with most European countries. With a
                set of electoral reforms the Monarchy advanced towards enforcing the universal
                manhood suffrage and also achieved it in 1907. The reasons for the Monarchy's tragic
                end lied primarily in the fatal lack of basic consensus on the matter of how the
                state should be organised. The latter was becoming increasingly evident in the
                Austrian parliamentary practice. Namely, since the end of the 19<hi
                    rend="superscript">th</hi> century the parliament had become the place of severe
                national conflicts with no room for an agreement.</p>
            <p>The present book is Cvirn’s final and most comprehensive work on the history of
                parliamentarism. The editor manly followed Cvirn's university textbook and strived
                to refrain from interfering with the text as much as possible. The author concludes
                the book with World War I. However, the editor completed Cvirn’s structure of the
                book by ending it with a few additional chapters written by the author (on the
                electoral reforms of the National Assembly, women’s suffrage, rules of procedure,
                language of proceedings, immunity of deputies, and deputies’ wages), which
                complement and clarify the primary text as well as underline the magnitude of the
                history of parliamentarism.</p>
        </body>
    </text>
</TEI>
